3 Common Pinterest Mistakes

Some links on this site are affiliate links, meaning I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I trust and use myself. Thank you for supporting my content!

3 Common Pinterest Mistakes Holding Your Traffic Back (and How to Fix Them!)

Pinterest can be an amazing traffic source, but only if your profile and pins are optimised to attract your ideal audience.


Recently, members of my PinPower Growth Academy took part in a challenge to polish their Pinterest presence, and they nailed it! Today, I'm sharing their fantastic results to show you how you can fix three common Pinterest mistakes.

Mistake #1: An Unclear or Unoptimised Profile

Your Pinterest profile is like your shop window, it needs to clearly show visitors what you offer. Many profiles are vague or missing essential information, which can leave pinners confused.


How to Fix It:

  • Include your main keywords in your profile name.
  • Write a clear, keyword-rich bio describing exactly how you help people.
  • Choose a professional, appealing profile picture.


Member Spotlight: Debbie from Debbie Joyful Designs updated her profile beautifully, clearly stating that she offers "Original artwork to help you share your faith." Now, her ideal customers immediately know they're in the right place.


Debbie helps Christians who are looking for gifts and cards with Scripture on them. You can visit her Pinterest Profile here.


Mistake #2: Missing or Ineffective Keywords

Without the right keywords, your ideal audience won't find your pins, no matter how beautiful they are.


How to Fix It:

  • Research Pinterest-specific keywords your audience uses.
  • Include these keywords naturally in your pin titles and descriptions.


Member Spotlight: Barbara from Love our Shops UK skillfully incorporated relevant keywords like "Dog training treats" and "Dog accessories" into her Pin title and description, ensuring her pins reach exactly the right audience.


Barbara inspires the nation to shop independent more and more everyday. You can visit her Pinterest Profile here.


Mistake #3: Pins That Don’t Attract Clicks

Even if Pinterest users see your pins, you won’t get traffic if the pins don’t invite a click.


How to Fix It:

  • Use clear, easy-to-read titles on pins.
  • Choose attractive visuals that match your audience's preferences.
  • Keep designs clean, professional, and consistent with your brand.


Member Spotlight: Helen from Ell Evan Bookkeeping created visually appealing, engaging pins with clear, enticing titles like "How much does it cost to sell on Etsy?" Her thoughtful design immediately encourages clicks.


Helen helps e-commerce business owners go from chaos to calm by removing their bookkeeping headaches. You can visit her Pinterest Profile here.


Ready to Boost Your Pinterest Results?

📌 Grab the free ‘What to Pin’ Cheat Sheet and discover ready-to-use content ideas tailored to your niche.

📌 Visit my Template Shop for easy-to-customise and high-converting pin templates for Canva

📌 Join the PinPower Growth Academy, my low-cost Pinterest membership provides you with everything you need to grow on Pinterest!

Pin Me!

Was this blog post helpful? Pin this blog to one of your boards to share it with your community and read it again later. I appreciate every single pin and share that I receive. 🧡